Fee calculator
Half a percent in fees sounds like very little. Over 20 or 30 years it can easily cost you tens of thousands of francs. Compare two providers for your pillar 3a or your investment account and see whether switching pays off, or whether it is enough to invest only your new contributions with the cheaper provider.
Your investment
You find the fees in the provider's price list or factsheet. If the provider has tiers by assets, enter the rate that applies to your balance.
If you switch
Lead over "Stay"
Above the zero line you have more money than with your current provider, below it less.
| Option | Assets at the end | Total fees | Difference to "Stay" |
|---|
Note: A simplified model with a constant return that is the same for both providers. Real markets fluctuate, and different investment strategies bring different returns. Taxes, exchange rates and the cash share of a strategy are not included. Not investment advice.
Comparing fees: how to use the calculator
Small percentages, big impact
Fees are deducted every year from your whole balance, not just from your contributions. So the amount grows along with your money, and the money taken out can no longer earn a return. In the example above (CHF 60'000 balance, CHF 7'258 per year, 25 years, 5% return before costs), fees of 0.55% instead of 0.35% per year add up to around CHF 18'000 by the end. Today the difference of CHF 120 per year still looks small.
What counts as fees
Management fee: what the provider charges for managing your account, usually as a percentage of assets per year. Product costs (TER): the ongoing costs of the funds or ETFs, listed in the factsheet and deducted directly from the price. Fixed costs: custody or account fees in francs. Costs per contribution: front-end loads or brokerage fees when buying. Less visible are the cash share of a strategy, which earns hardly anything, and currency exchange fees on investments in dollars or euros.
Switch everything or only new contributions?
The calculator shows three options. Stay: everything stays with your current provider. Switch everything: you transfer the whole balance and your new contributions go to the new provider too. You pay switching costs once, and the money is out of the market for a few days. New contributions only: your balance stays where it is and from now on you pay into the new provider. This costs nothing to switch, but the old balance keeps carrying the higher fees. The chart shows when a switch has made up for the one-off costs.
Pillar 3a: what applies when you switch
A transfer between two 3a providers is not a withdrawal, so no tax is due. You always transfer a whole 3a account. With securities, the current provider sells the units and transfers the money, and the new one buys again. The transfer itself is usually free, but some banks require a notice period or charge a fee, so check the regulations. You may hold several 3a accounts, also with different providers. Several accounts can later help you spread the withdrawal over several years. Your contributions together must not exceed the annual maximum. More in our pillar 3a guide.
Compare similar strategies
The calculator assumes the same return for both providers. That works if the strategies are similar, for example a similar share of equities and similar markets. If one provider holds a lot more equities, the expected return is higher and fluctuates more, which often moves the result more than the fees. The compound interest calculator shows what your savings plan can grow into over the years, and the pillar 3a calculator shows the tax savings of pillar 3a.
FAQ on fees and switching providers
Is it worth switching my pillar 3a?
It depends on the difference in fees, on your balance and on the time until you withdraw. The calculator shows when a switch has made up for the one-off costs and how much more or less money you have at the end. Compare strategies with a similar share of equities.
What does a pillar 3a transfer cost?
The transfer itself is usually free. With securities, however, there are costs for selling and buying, and the money is not invested during the transfer, often for a few weeks. Some banks require a notice period or charge a fee. Enter these costs in the field "One-off switching costs".
Can I pay only my new contributions into the new provider?
Yes. You may hold several 3a accounts with different providers, as long as your contributions together do not exceed the annual maximum. Your existing balance then keeps carrying the fees of the old provider. If an account has fixed costs, you pay them for both accounts, and the calculator includes them.
What is the difference between the management fee and the TER?
The management fee is what the provider charges for managing your account. The TER (total expense ratio) is the ongoing cost of the funds or ETFs your money is invested in. Both are deducted from your assets, so the calculator adds them up.
Why does the calculator use the same return for both providers?
So that only the fees make the difference. If the strategies differ, for example 60% versus 95% equities, the expected return and the fluctuations differ too. No calculator can predict that difference reliably.
All your accounts in one place
Geldfuchs shows your pillar 3a, investment accounts and bank accounts together and projects your retirement savings up to retirement, taxed for your canton.